Current:Home > MyAppeals court: Separate, distinct minority groups can’t join together to claim vote dilution-LoTradeCoin
Appeals court: Separate, distinct minority groups can’t join together to claim vote dilution
View Date:2024-12-24 07:44:30
NEW ORLEANS (AP) — Distinct minority groups cannot join together in coalitions to claim their votes are diluted in redistricting cases under the Voting Rights Act, a divided federal appeals court ruled Thursday, acknowledging that it was reversing years of its own precedent.
At issue was a redistricting case in Galveston County, Texas, where Black and Latino groups had joined to challenge district maps drawn by the county commission. A federal district judge had rejected the maps, saying they diluted minority strength. A three-judge panel of the New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals initially upheld the decision before the full court decided to reconsider the issue, resulting in Thursday’s 12-6 decision.
Judge Edith Jones, writing for the majority, said such challenges by minority coalitions “do not comport” with Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act and are not supported by Supreme Court precedent The decision reverses a 1988 5th Circuit decision and is likely to be appealed to the Supreme Court.
“Nowhere does Section 2 indicate that two minority groups may combine forces to pursue a vote dilution claim,” Jones, nominated to the court by former President Ronald Reagan, wrote. “On the contrary, the statute identifies the subject of a vote dilution claim as ‘a class,’ in the singular, not the plural.”
Jones was joined by 11 other nominees of Republican presidents on the court. Dissenting were five members nominated by Democratic presidents and one nominee of a Republican president. The 5th Circuit reviews cases from federal district courts in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi.
“Today, the majority finally dismantled the effectiveness of the Voting Rights Act in this circuit, leaving four decades of en banc precedent flattened in its wake,” dissenting Judge Dana Douglas, nominated to the court by President Joe Biden. Her dissent noted that Galveston County figures prominently in the nation’s Juneteenth celebrations, marking the date in 1865, when Union soldiers told enslaved Black people in Galveston that they had been freed.
“To reach its conclusion, the majority must reject well-established methods of statutory interpretation, jumping through hoops to find exceptions,” Douglas wrote.
veryGood! (14534)
Related
- NATO’s Rutte calls for more Western support for Ukraine, warns of Russian alliances
- New Trump Nuclear Plan Favors Uranium Mining Bordering the Grand Canyon
- West Virginia's COVID vaccine lottery under scrutiny over cost of prizes, tax issues
- Transcript: Sen. Richard Blumenthal on Face the Nation, June 18, 2023
- Mike Tyson vs. Jake Paul press conference highlights: 'Problem Child' goads 'Iron Mike'
- 80-hour weeks and roaches near your cot? More medical residents unionize
- Medicare tests a solution to soaring hospice costs: Let private insurers run it
- This Week in Clean Economy: Green Cards for Clean Energy Job Creators
- Judge sets April trial date for Sarah Palin’s libel claim against The New York Times
- Vitamix 24-Hour Deal: Save 46% On a Blender That Functions as a 13-In-1 Machine
Ranking
- Martha Stewart playfully pushes Drew Barrymore away in touchy interview
- Q&A: Black scientist Antentor Hinton Jr. talks role of Juneteenth in STEM, need for diversity in field
- Padel, racket sport played in at least 90 countries, is gaining attention in U.S.
- How A New Majority On Wisconsin's Supreme Court Could Impact Reproductive Health
- Record-setting dry conditions threaten more US wildfires, drinking water supplies
- Today's election could weaken conservatives' long-held advantage in Wisconsin
- Q&A: Plug-In Leader Discusses Ups and Downs of America’s E.V. Transformation
- What we know about the Indiana industrial fire that's forced residents to evacuate
Recommendation
-
Denver district attorney is investigating the leak of voting passwords in Colorado
-
Medicare tests a solution to soaring hospice costs: Let private insurers run it
-
Soaring Costs Plague California Nuke Plant Shut Down By Leak
-
Duracell With a Twist: Researchers Find Fix for Grid-Scale Battery Storage
-
The Daily Money: Mattel's 'Wicked' mistake
-
Ireland is paying up to $92,000 to people who buy homes on remote islands. Here's how it works.
-
Greening of Building Sector on Track to Deliver Trillions in Savings by 2030
-
One month after attack in congressman's office, House panel to consider more security spending